Monday: Comics, Tuesday: Youth Orgs, Wednesday: Classics, Thursday: Life/Languages, Friday: Science Fiction and Fantasy
Monday, May 30, 2022
M.O.M
Wednesday, May 25, 2022
Two and Half Feet in an Elegiac Trenchcoat
In preparing for the June sampler of the Greek group, I was reminded how the second part of the elegiac couplet, the dactylic pentameter, resembles its lankier predecessor not so much as a younger sibling as much as a burn victim whose skin has been removed from one area to patch another, a Frankenstein of metrical composition. The dactylic hexameter is a well-behaved meter, rarely breaking its structure for moments of deep pathos or extraordinary gravity; the iambic pentameter, however, rather than losing a foot before the final spondee, amputates the spondee in order to graft a long syllable as the second-and-a-half foot, while extending the rigidity of the final dactyl and spondee (despondent for its other half?) to the entire latter half of the line. The iambic pentameter is a pair of two-and-half dactyls (Idaean or Cretan, they are always male) masquerading as a longer line.
If we switch to a more sober frame of mind, like the Medes upon the eve of a great decision, the hemiepes (for that is its name) is a more rational construction, although one would still think that half an epes (dactylic hexameter) would have three full feet. The elimination of the dibrach (two shorts) after the long is suggestive of the principle of brevis in longo, whereby even a syllable short in prose is treated as long at the end of the line; the dissonance comes from the two hemiepes (is the plural hemiepeis?) united in one line, thereby stranding what would have been a final syllable displaying brevis in longo as an orphaned syllable before the caesura. There are two explanation I can think for this. The first, closer to epic, is that the caesura in epes often falls after the first (long) syllable of the third foot, and therefore is the appropriate place for bisecting the meter; the second, closer to lyric, is that a three-line stanza of an epes and two hemiepes would not admit sufficient flexibility in the second line. I am inclined toward the former, if only because a half line with the caesura after the first short of the third foot of a dactylic hexameter would be subject to brevis in longo and therefore result in a half line indistinguishable from the latter half of a dactylic hexameter. But the resolution (pun intended) of this question admits of diverse answers.
Monday, May 23, 2022
X-Men '92: Thoughts
I meant to pick up X-Men '97 (forgetting that it was a different format and yet unreleased). So I ended up with X-Men '92. X-Men '92 is a continuation of the X-Men-focused fragment of Battleworld, the pastiche world created by God Emperor Doom from the remnants of the multiverse. Sadly, the only thing Vancean about this pastiche is a lot of Paos in battle. X-Men '92 was a testing ground for the continuing animation of X-Men '97 (which is the why the voices of the voice actors and the characterizations in the comic matched well). Fortunately, too characters and a complicated backstory is par for the course for the X-Men franchise; I'm old enough to remember the spinner racks where, if you missed an issue, or even worse, if the key event occurred in an annual, you just shrugged and read on. The advantage of the comics medium is that you can have far more characters, including short appearances, than you could with an auditory medium. The wordiness in this comic is almost Claremontian, a nice touch.
The story of the X-Men being temporarily tricked and who is good and who is bad being reshuffled is standard X-Men fare, well-written but not revolutionary. The writers and artists took advantage of this limited opportunity to introduce as many of the X-Men characters as possible - with the notable exception of Grant Morrison's X-Men run. There is no Wither or Wallflower here. Perhaps these characters are being held in reserve in favor of X-Force, New Mutants, and Generation X, and would have appeared in the second volume?
Wednesday, May 18, 2022
Island in the Sea of Time
Snake Island, the island off the Romanian coast from which the Ukrainian soldiers shouted words as vociferous, if not as grandiose as some Laconic words of defiance has a history stretching back into the Greek myths. Upon this island lay the temple of Achilles, where now the lighthouse stands; on its model the Greeks constructed Elysium; on these shores Circe (in some accounts) absolved her niece Medea of the murder of her brother Absyrtus (whose resemblance to Abzu, the watery consort of Tiamat, does not pass unnoticed). Pindar's Olympic Ode 2 mentions the Tower of Kronos in the Islands of Blest. If any island should represent the ghosts and sorrows of war, it is this island.
Monday, May 16, 2022
Trial of the Amazons: Thoughts
Friday, May 13, 2022
Continuity and Character Development: The Marvelous Land of Oz, Part 1
The plot of The Marvelous Land of Oz is an elaborate
card trick played upon the stage. The Wizard of Oz show was a success, and
therefore a new show was called for. The Marvelous Land of Oz was a
script for that new show. Not all characters from the book had been translated
to the stage, most notably the Lion (replaced by Elsie the Cow), so the archetypes
that Baum used for The Marvelous Land of Oz were as follows: Dorothy,
Scarecrow, Tin Woodman, Toto, Wizard, and Wicked Witch. Baum, however, faced a
challenge he had not previously encountered: continuity. All his previous
fairylands had been separate countries, but now he was returning (at least in
book form) to the same country. The popular characters from the previous work had
to appear, but the familiar characters could not occupy the same archetype
because they had completed that portion of their story. At the same time, the new characters could not
entirely repeat the vacant archetypes; that would remove any surprises.
Finally, the conclusion of the second trip to Oz needed to conclude in such a
way that Baum could move on to other fairylands; Baum therefore created a magic
trick in the form of a play.
The first difference between The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
and The Marvelous Land of Oz is the initial location. This story starts
within Oz. The Land of the Gillikins, the northern land neglected in the
original, becomes the starting point.
There must be a wicked witch and an oppressed child. The Wicked Witches
of Oz are dead, so this witch, Mombi, is not allowed to be an official witch,
but she is wicked. The Good Witch of the North is mentioned as the author of this
“one witch at a time” decree, but she is not the witch (not even the Good
Witch) relevant to the story. Mombi’s status as potential Witch is cemented by
her connection both with a crooked magician and the Wizard. The Wizard, of
course, has returned to our world, so cannot be part of this story, but Mombi’s
connection with the Wizard is the first clue that there is a mystery to be
solved. Trafficking with the Wizard contrasts with the attitudes of the Witches
in the first book, where they prefer to keep their distance from the Wizard, as
well as indicating that there is further imbalance in Oz that requires
correction.
The oppressed child, although he is not particularly
oppressed but modern literary standards, is Tippetarius, also known as Tip. He
is, of course, effectively an orphan. The relationship between Tip, our primary
Dorothy replacement, and Mombi is reminiscent of that between the Tin Woodman
and his witch, as well as that between the Tin Woodman’s female love interest
and the witch who employed her. While Mombi is off to the black market to
defraud and possibly be defrauded, Tip, whose ethics are somewhat lacking
through no fault of his own, constructs a man out of sticks with a pumpkin for
a head to scare Mombi. Tip has neither magic nor narrative power, so the sticks
remain sticks. When Mombi comes across the stick man and is not alarmed, she
uses the magical gimmick, the Powder of Life, to give the figure life and dubs
him Jack Pumpkinhead; thus we have an occupant for the Scarecrow archetype. A
living stick man who does not eat is cheaper than a flesh and blood boy who
does, so Mombi decides to change Tip into a (apparently alive) garden statue.
This seems at first glance an act of gratuitous cruelty, but it cements Tip’s archetype
as the Tin Woodman as well as Dorothy. This
transformation, however, will have to wait for tomorrow, since potion making is
a lengthy process. Mombi’s assumption that Tip will not leave and will
voluntarily drink the petrifaction potion illustrates how much control Mombi
believes she has over Tip. This control is illusory, which is interesting
because her primary magic skill is illusion. The long-term motivation for
petrifaction might be a fear of Mombi that Tip will rat her out to the Good
Witch of the North directly or indirectly, but Mombi’s trafficking with the
Wizard, the bretwalda of Oz, suggests substantially greater problems. Tip
fulfills his obligation as Dorothy by freeing Jack, but their departure
together displays Tin Woodman elements, because Jack is a magical toddler and
does not come possessed of the sagacity which the Scarecrow received, even
though Jack is structurally more like the Tin Woodman than Tip. It is also
possible to miss the Scarecrow element of Jack if the party’s numbers are the
only consideration, since Tip and Jack are travelling to see the actual
Scarecrow in the Emerald City.
Tip and Jack have an important conversation about their
relationship. Jack maintains that Tip is his father because he constructed him.
Tip points out it was Mombi who sprinkled him with the Powder of Life and
therefore would be his mother. Jack insists that Tip is his real parent because
if Tip had not created him, he would not have existed at all; moreover, nobody
would choose Mombi as a parent, adoptive or biological. This discussion introduces
parentage as a major element of the story, but also temporarily deflects the
question of parentage to the sidekick rather than the protagonist.
Wednesday, May 11, 2022
Alis in Waunderland
I’ve been reading Pindar’s Olympian Ode 1. Every ode has a victor which it celebrates and almost every ode has a mythological antecedent. The Olympic victor here is Hieron, tyrant of Syracuse, while the mythological antecedent is Pelops, son of Tantalus. The story which Pindar tells about Pelops is different from the usual tale; but Pelops returns to the mortal realm either way. Once Pelops is growing into a young man, he needs to find a bride, so he decides to enter the contest for the hand of Hippodamia, daughter of Oenomaus of Pisa, a city near Olympia. The successful suitor receives Hippodamia as a bride; the unsuccessful suitors receive death, because myth never does anything halfway. Pisa and Olympia are in the land of Elis, or at least that is how the Attic Greek of Athens would render it. In the Ode, which is written in the Doric Greek of Thebes, the land is Alis, showing the long alpha for eta correspondence used (and sometimes abused) in certain parts of Greek poetry. In the land of Elis (or Alis) itself, the Doric Greek dialect is yet more archaic: it retains the digamma or wau lost in more rapidly developing dialects, and therefore Elis in Elean Greek is Walis or Valis (the digamma is sometimes rendered as beta in Greek which lacks it). This name, as speakers of Latin might notice, means ‘valley’ or ‘hollow’, which makes the subdistrict of Hollow Elis a Torpenhow Hill or Caermarthen Castle. The land, therefore, in which the Olympics occurred shares a name with a Swiss canton because humans are not very imaginative when it comes to naming things – the name Pisa is basically Las Vegas.
Monday, May 9, 2022
Young Justice (Rebirth): Continuous Continuity Confusion
Friday, May 6, 2022
Do They Know It's Christmas in (Fantasy) Africa?
If the sections of Baum's Land of Oz are reflective of portions of America (Munchkin land is the populous East, Winkie Country is the West, Quadling Country is the swampy and isolated South, and the Emerald City is Chicago), is the much less well-known Island of Yew a fantasy Africa? The entirety of the island is abundant with sorcerors, although not as many as the Yewsians would have potential enemies believe. The north is a land of feuding, bloody baronies, much like the Barbary states of the Mediterranean and bandits reminiscent of the Senussi slave routes from the Niger to Cyrene. The west is characterized by a flim-flam sorceror, similar to the European perception of voudoun, along with the attendant suckers, and a magical land of twins, much like the twin statues of the Gulf of Africa. The east is a land of cattle raiders, which matches the cattle-raiding culture of Bantu tribes of East Africa. The center is unknown and as mysterious to the travelers as the Mountains of the Moon, full of monsters. The south. of course, is dominated by a ruby-themed good sorceress who maintains civilization (God save the Queen!). Fairies are needed to guide places and people that are not civilized; once a place is civilized, the fairies do not need to intervene and any remnants of the pre-civilized edge will be out of place.
On the other hand, much of this directional theme could be overlaid on Europe in certain periods.
Monday, May 2, 2022
Not All Women (Are Museless)
The Legend of Wonder Woman is a 2016 series by writer/artist Renae de Liz and artist Ray Dillon which tells its own version of Diana’s entry into the world. The style is a bit too 3D for my taste, but that is now a common style and does not detract from the story. I have the issues for about half the series; unfortunately, I misestimated where it ended and at the time I did not have it on my pull list. When I saw it in the local branch, I immediately grabbed it.
In this version of Themyscira, the Amazons believe
themselves to be the survivors of an apocalyptic Titanomachy, although with one
“Titan”. The rest of the world is seen as barren wasteland. The majority of the
Amazons are mortal. So why are there still Amazons? Some Amazons, those whom
the gods deem most suitable for the task, are designated to be mothers to the
souls of girls, presumably from the pool of all women. The race of Amazons is
small enough to avoid psychic recycling.
These mortal Amazons live their best lives in paradise and die happy. A
few Amazons, including Queen Hippolyta, are immortal, but immortality always
comes with a price. In this case, the price is childlessness. The other
immortal Amazons can accept this, sometimes reluctantly, but Hippolyta cannot. Hippolyta
molds a statue out of the clay of Themyscira and prays to the gods to give her
a daughter. The statue comes to life as Diana, an immortal child. These details
are important to Diana’s childhood. Although she is not the only child, she is
the only immortal one. She has a destiny, like all Amazons; hers is to become
queen after Hippolyta. This destiny, unfortunately, suffers from a breakdown in
logic: if Hippolyta is immortal, then Diana will never become Queen. Although
Diana is referred to as a Princess, it does not have the same connotation on
Themyscira, since the two functions of an only child of the monarch, succession
and marriage, are not relevant. When Etta Candy later describes Diana as a
princess, she must think about it for second; this would be a strange reaction
from a mortal royal. Diana, the immortal child, but fortunately not in the vampire
child way, is an anomaly, and her anomalous nature enables her to detect other
anomalies.
Paradise never lasts, much like childhood, and disturbances begin
to gnaw at the peace of Themyscira. The rot is reminiscent of that found in
Disney’s Moana. The inevitable plane crash occurs with Steve Trevor as
the pilot. The Amazons in charge of the defense of the island want to kill him,
but Diana nurses him back to health. This recuperation, of course, means
someone must pierce the veil to return him to Man’s World. There must be a
contest of volunteers to determine this. The point of contention here is that
passing through the veil causes amnesia for intruders and a ban on returning. Diana wants to enter; her mother forbids it;
she enters anonymously; she wins; her mother gives her the paraphernalia. This
is as inevitable as Krypton exploding (since Thomas Wayne is now a Batman).
Diana passes through the veil, but she manages to lose Steve,
presumed dead. Diana is now depressed because she both failed on her first mission
objective and can never return home. She is, however, pleasantly surprised at
the non-wasteland of the outside world. She is welcomed, despite being a
stranger in wartime, by a kindly elderly couple, who may be an oblique
reference to the Kents (the wife certainly exudes Ma Kent vibes), but its
coastal setting suggests Aquaman. After she has recuperated, she heads into
town, which includes Holliday College. Her youthfulness and Greco-roman outfit
lead the college students to assume she is one of their peers (and possibly
drunk, since she falls out of a tree in the make-out corner of campus). Etta
Candy, in all her Forties campus gal glory, rescues Diana by claiming she is her
cousin from Gargantuania; this is both a reference to the villain Gargantua and
the way that Diana replaces the member of the Golden Age Holliday Girls whose
personality was being very tall (the very short one is present). A reference to
Gargantua and Pantagruel seems a bit deeper than this series would go.
This story is about Etta and Diana, not Steve and Diana. If
they are more than friends, there is no explicit reference – but it seems less
likely in the Forties (pace fans of a certain author). Etta directs her characteristic
enthusiasm towards boys, and Diana would like to hook up with Steve, but the
mission takes precedence. This version of Etta is an update of the comic
sidekick, stripped of some of the elements that would appear mean-spirited
today. Etta’s comedic plot is her life-long rivalry with her hometown nemesis,
Pamela Smuthers, now expressed through musical competition; the Holliday Girls
are not just sorority sisters, but a musical group (thankfully this time
without the Mexican stereotypes) who are this world’s Andrews Sisters. Smuthers
naturally shows up every time Etta is about to perform.
After the domestic comedy, including Diana’s poor taste in
clothes while shopping, her unfamiliarity with the concept of movies, and her
anger at the misrepresentation of her mother in A Midsummer Night’s Dream, it
is time for Etta and Diana to go to Europe. This is not easy in the middle of a
war. Etta’s impetus to leave for the front is an unflattering ad from the Candy
family business featuring Etta; she hopes that she can both avoid the
embarrassment at home and make her name as a singer on the front. Diana’s
impetus is to find the Duke of Deception, whose jewel she recognizes and whose existence
is guaranteed by a news reporter named Perry. Diana signs up solely as a nurse
so that she can have access to the news from the front. Steve is around and
teaches Diana important Chekov’s skills, but Etta is still more important.
The treatment of race in this book is interesting. The appalling
excesses of the Golden Age comics are thankfully absent, but the presence of an
integrated campus and military with the absence of any comment on race is a bit
odd. It is true that later war stories projected integration back on World War
Two, and Etta’s libido is as outsized as any of her other appetites, but the
only reasonable conclusion is that focusing on race would be a different Wonder
Woman story with a different villain.
When the Duke of Deception starts raising the dead, which
itself could be a reference to a real incident on the Eastern Front, Diana springs
into action as Wonder Woman. This heroism leads to the troops regarding her as their
hero. Although this is a Wonder Woman story, superheroes do exist – enough that
there is a JSA, which includes at least Hourman; thus she is not the lone hero
of this earth. Why the other heroes are not in Europe is not answered; but
perhaps the sole mention of Hourman suggests no mystical or mythical heroes,
and Clark Kent failed his eye exam.
Wonder Woman is on an upward track until Zeus, who has
apparently finally noticed Diana using Hippolyta’s paraphernalia, summons Diana
before him. Zeus offers to make her his champion against the Titan, whom Ares
is attempting to raise using the Duke of Deception’s campaign of death and
misery. Zeus is best known for being a lecher, but his most relevant quality
here is his unbending authoritarianism. If Diana agrees to be his champion, she
will receive greater power than she already possesses, but she must abide by
Zeus’ rules. Since this is a duel, if the Titan wins, Diana’s friends are fair
game for the Titan. Diana does not mind dying for her friends, but she is not
willing to abandon them and the rest of the world to destruction. Zeus, who is
petty in all the ways that a being of immense power can get away with, strips
Diana of all her powers save natural Amazonian athleticism.
The Titan rises. The air corps flies off to meet their doom.
Diana steals the invisible jet on which Steve trained her in one lesson, with
the Holliday Girls as her crew. This chutzpah is true to the spirit of the Golden
Age Holliday Girls. Diana confronts the Titan without her powers but is
summoned again before a god. This time Gaia, the Earth, reveals that Diana is
the last child of Gaia and bestows upon her the powers which Zeus had removed. This
reveal is interesting because in Classical Greek mythology Gaia was the mother
of monsters rather than the mother of the champion against monsters. Gaia was
the mother of the Classical Titans, but this Titan is not the child of Gaia,
but rather a being from the stars, a robotic Manhunter. These Manhunters began
as just, but they became corrupted over time and more dogmatic. The Manhunter
that fell to Earth tried to purge it, but Zeus’ attempt to destroy the Titan through
control of his champion decimated Earth almost as much as a Titan victory would
have done. The Amazons’ isolation preserved a piece of paradise, but stagnation
was the price of immortality. Redemption required a mortal impulse from an
immortal made immortal rather than a natural immortal; this mortal impulse
produced a member of the immortal society who could not fit in, and therefore
would experience both worlds in the way that Zeus could not and Hippolyta would
not. The champion of both worlds needed to care about both portions to defend
the entire Earth from a threat beyond the stars.
On a more personal level, the Duke of Deception turns out to
be a regular human, Thomas Byde, who sent his little brother away from present
danger. He dies in a bombing anyway. Thomas feels guilt over this, and Ares exploits
this guilt to manipulate him. Thomas flies to Mars and lives there alone in the
former habitation of his master; a cruel fate, but one that contrasts with the
communal life on Themyscira.